Shoppers dutifully scan their loyalty cards at the checkout, week after week, only to find a few targeted discounts and a handful of coupons they never use. Now, a retail expert says one discount chain has finally changed the rules of the game with what he calls the first “real” loyalty programme.
Why most supermarket loyalty cards feel pointless
Almost every major supermarket pushes a loyalty scheme. The pitch is familiar: the card is free, registration takes seconds, and you’ll “save all year round”. At the till, it often feels easier to say yes than to argue.
Yet once the card is in your wallet or app, the disappointment sets in. You keep spending, but your monthly bill barely shifts. Any “rewards” you receive are usually heavily targeted promotions on specific brands or product ranges.
For many shoppers, loyalty cards work more as marketing tools than as genuine reward systems.
Consumer specialist Olivier Dauvers, a well-known analyst of the French retail sector, argues that most supermarket schemes confuse loyalty with opportunism. Instead of rewarding consistent spending at one chain, they reward people who chase the right offers at the right time.
Promotions first, loyalty second
According to Dauvers, the majority of loyalty programmes in large retailers are essentially sophisticated promotion engines. Points, vouchers or “personalised offers” mostly apply to specific products pushed by brands or the supermarket itself.
- A customer who rarely shops at a store can still collect big rewards by hitting all the right promo triggers.
- A loyal customer who buys mainly basics or non-promotional items may see very little back.
- The system often encourages switching products, not staying loyal to the retailer.
That structure suits supermarkets and brands, because it nudges customers towards certain products, often with higher margins. For households, it creates the feeling of savings without necessarily cutting the overall grocery bill.
Lidl changes the rules with a clear points system
One chain, though, has decided to shift focus from product-led perks to a very simple spending-reward mechanic. Lidl, the German discount giant with a growing footprint across Europe, has updated its digital loyalty app, Lidl Plus, with a new points-based system tied directly to how much shoppers spend.
Lidl’s new model: every euro spent earns one point, with rewards unlocked purely on accumulated spending.
➡️ Rare celestial show not to miss: 6 planets visible at the same time
➡️ What psychology reveals about people who need time alone after positive social moments
➡️ Lidl knocks €600 off this electric bike for the next few days and not everyone is happy about it
➡️ The little-known trick to remove sticker residue from glass without scraping and zero effort
➡️ How to make an aloe vera face cream to boost collagen and care for your skin
Launched in February in France and expected to influence other markets in time, the revamped scheme applies an easy rule: 1 euro spent equals 1 point. No complicated tiers for specific brands, no need to pick the “right” discounted items just to unlock a reward.
How the new Lidl Plus works
With the updated system, customers collect points each time they scan their Lidl Plus app at the till. As their total grows, they gain access to free products from a rotating selection.
The monthly rewards catalogue typically includes basics such as:
- Fresh fruit and vegetables
- Meat and poultry
- Fish and seafood
- Everyday grocery items
To claim these rewards, shoppers activate digital coupons in the app, then scan the app at checkout. The free item is deducted automatically when the conditions are met.
Dauvers notes that Lidl can also add “incentives” on top of the base rule: for example, double points days, extra points on specific categories, or bonus points for trying new services.
Why experts call it a “real” loyalty programme
For Dauvers, the key difference lies in what the programme truly rewards. Instead of favouring shoppers who jump between products and promotions, Lidl’s scheme primarily advantages those who consistently do their main weekly shop there.
The bigger your annual spend at Lidl, the more points you earn, and the more real groceries you can get for free.
This structure puts the “loyalty” back in loyalty programme. The main criteria is not whether you chose the right brand of cereal on a given week, but whether you regularly fill your trolley at the same supermarket.
| Traditional loyalty card | Lidl Plus points system |
|---|---|
| Rewards tied to specific brands and promos | Rewards tied to total spending |
| Occasional big wins if you hit the right offers | Steady accumulation based on every shop |
| Encourages product switching | Encourages store loyalty |
| Complex conditions and small print | Simple 1 € = 1 point rule |
What this means for your grocery budget
A simple points system makes it easier for households to forecast actual savings. Instead of waiting for unpredictable vouchers, you can estimate roughly how many free products you’ll receive over a year based on your spending.
Take a family who spends €100 a week at Lidl. Over 12 months, that’s around €5,200, or 5,200 points under the new rule. If the programme converts those points into a steady stream of free essentials each month, the effective discount becomes tangible, not theoretical.
For shoppers used to feeling tricked by loyalty card marketing, this transparency can rebuild trust. You see a direct, measurable link between your loyalty and your benefits.
The hidden trade-off: your data
There is a trade-off. Digital loyalty apps like Lidl Plus collect detailed information on what you buy, when you shop, and how much you spend. This data helps retailers refine pricing, stock management and personalised offers.
The more transparent the rewards, the more comfortable many customers feel about sharing their data.
For privacy-conscious shoppers, the key question is whether the benefits justify that data exchange. A clear, generous and easy-to-understand reward structure makes that bargain easier to accept than a vague promise of “member prices”.
How to judge if a loyalty card really pays off
With Lidl raising the bar, other supermarkets may respond by rethinking their own schemes. For shoppers, that creates an opportunity to assess which loyalty cards actually help reduce the grocery bill.
Several questions can guide that assessment:
- Is the main reward based on total spending, or on specific promoted products?
- Can you easily calculate what you gain over a month or a year?
- Are the rewards items you would genuinely buy anyway?
- Does the app or card encourage you to overspend to chase points?
Programmes that reward you with everyday staples you already purchase usually bring more value than those that tempt you into buying extras just to unlock a coupon.
Practical scenarios for everyday shoppers
Imagine two different strategies over six months:
- Customer A splits their shopping across three supermarkets, chasing the best weekly deals but earning only scattered points on each card.
- Customer B does nearly all their shopping at Lidl, steadily collecting points under the 1 € = 1 point rule.
Customer A might feel clever week to week, but could end up with a handful of small vouchers and unused product-specific coupons. Customer B might pay slightly more for an item here and there, but sees a clear return in the form of regular free staples funded by a large cumulative spend.
Over time, a simple loyalty structure can favour consistent habits, especially for families with predictable shopping lists and limited time to chase offers.
Beyond Lidl: what shoppers can expect next
Lidl’s move puts pressure on rivals to show that their loyalty schemes are more than flashy apps and targeted ads. Chains heavily invested in “member prices” and complex tiers may face questions from customers who now expect straightforward spending-based rewards.
Shoppers could soon see a wave of adjustments: more transparent points systems, clearer thresholds for rewards, and fewer baffling conditions in the small print. At the same time, retailers will continue to balance generous rewards with tight margins, especially in a period of high food inflation.
For households, the best approach is to treat loyalty cards like any other financial tool: check the rules, run the numbers, and focus on programmes where your regular habits genuinely pay you back in real, usable savings.